Statement of claim concerning documents on noise pollution
The Foundation asked the court to order DSP Satu Mare to disclose the requested documents.
Freies EuropaDocuments in the collection concerning access to information of public interest.
The Foundation asked the court to order DSP Satu Mare to disclose the requested documents.
Allows the action and orders SPP to disclose copies of protocols concluded in the period 01.01.1990–01.12.2018 with the entities listed in the request, except for the classified protocols, which it must specifically identify.
Contains two MAI inventories: a record of the 128 unclassified protocols and the list of 37 classified protocols, with the identifying details and comments recorded by the Ministry.
Dismisses SPP’s appeal on points of law: the requester’s interest derives from the law, and protocols are exempt from disclosure only insofar as they fall within the categories of classified information.
Dismisses MAI’s appeal on points of law and upholds the obligation to disclose the unclassified protocols, identifying the documents that are classified.
Allows the ANAF president’s appeal on points of law, quashes Civil Judgment No. 753/2018/CA and dismisses as unfounded FEW’s action seeking a fine, finding that disclosure of the protocol had been proved.
Discloses protocols in compliance with Judgment No. 131/CA/2019, which became final through Decision No. 801/CA/2019-R.
Supplements the earlier responses and lists protocols, cooperation programmes and a memorandum, grouped by partners in Romania or other states.
Discloses two protocols identified in the institution’s records; Decision No. 449/CA/2019-R records compliance with the first-instance judgment through this disclosure.
Discloses protocols in compliance with Civil Judgment No. 305/2019/CA and lists three classified protocols that are exempt from disclosure.